HOW TO SURVIVE A DIVORCE
Divorce may well be one of the more traumatic experiences you will ever know. It's important to realize that COMMON SENSE and a spirit of COOPERATION can be the two key ingredients in reducing the stress and anger so often associated with this trying time in your life. Only one person will benefit from your conflict and bitterness - your attorney, in the form of the higher fees he will be forced to charge to resolve your difficulties. So, take a deep breath, speak calmly to one another, and try to work out your differences BEFORE consulting your lawyer. I guarantee that you'll be better off in the long run, both emotionally and in terms of the lower legal fees that will result.
Property Division
One of the most hotly contested issues in many divorces is the property settlement. Issues about "who gets what" can prolong a case indefinitely, resulting in abysmally high legal fees and irreparably damaged feelings. However much you may feel you have been injured, you should know that in the vast majority of cases, a Court will not take "fault" into account when determining a property settlement. These days, most divorces are filed on the basis of mutual incompatibility, so fault does not even enter into the equation. What the Court does look at is EQUITY - that is, what would be fair and reasonable in a given situation.
For example, a wife in a 25-year marriage who had never worked outside the home could reasonably request alimony. However, if that wife had worked throughout the marriage at a well-paying job, or if the marriage had been of a much shorter duration, then alimony would not be considered reasonable in the majority of cases. Nor should an "injured" party feel that he or she has an absolute right to full ownership of the house, the cars, the furniture, the pets, the investment account, etc. - in short, taking your spouse "to the cleaners" is a long and expensive process, rarely resulting in success.
It is strongly recommended that a divorcing couple sit down and calmly discuss their financial situation prior to meeting with a lawyer. Whenever a contested item arises, always ask yourself, "What is the fairest thing to do in this situation?" Many couples make the unfortunate mistake of insisting upon ownership of certain items simply out of spite or wounded feelings. Don't let this happen to you. In the end you will both pay the price for that stubbornness. If the bone of contention involves smaller items (such as household goods and furniture), then one way of avoiding conflict is simply to make a list of all items in dispute and take turns picking what you want, irrespective of value (after all, you may find a $10.00 item with sentimental value of more worth to you than the most expensive piece of furniture which your spouse may pick). However, if you can't come to terms about the more valuable property in dispute, such as the house, IRA, etc., then the Judge, or a mediator, will have to make that determination for you. So, ask yourself, "Who knows the situation better - a Judge who has never met us before in his life, or my spouse and I?" If you answer that question honestly, you will have taken the first step in working out your difficulties with less expense and frustration.
Your First Priority - The Children
What should always be in the forefront of your thoughts is the well-being of your children. Never forget that they are the most innocent victims of a divorce. After all, although you and your spouse have (to whatever degree) chosen to end your marriage and get on with your lives, your children never had a say in the break-up of their family life. And, make no mistake, you ARE breaking up more than just your own marriage - every aspect of your children's lives will be changed, and usually not for the better. If you keep their welfare clearly in mind, they can come out of this process without the scars associated with a bitter and contentious divorce.
- DON'T say negative things about your spouse in front of the children - that person is still their parent. Always remember that two can play at that game - and do you really want your children hearing all the private details of your married life?
- DON'T force the children to choose between the two of you. It is heartbreaking when children are taught that loving one parent means rejecting the other.
- DON'T use the children as "messengers" between their parents. If you can't be adult enough to talk to your spouse directly, then find some means of communication other than through the children. No child should ever have to ask a parent, "Daddy (or Mommy) - when are you going to send the child support check?"
- DON'T limit your spouse's contact with the children - they need constant contact with both parents in order to grow into secure and confident adults. Most especially, don't turn one parent into a "holiday" parent - seeing the children only on occasional weekends or holidays. As most people know from their own lives, many of the best memories of childhood come not from the trips to Disneyland or the beach, but from the ordinary, day-to-day activities of just being together.
- DON'T use your children as weapons against your spouse in the divorce - that weapon could blow up in your face - to your everlasting regret.
- If you are the one paying child support, DON'T assume that the children's needs can always be completely met by that court-ordered amount. Of course your spouse has a similar obligation to support his/her children. However, children are expensive creatures and emergencies crop up all the time. Your inflexibility regarding finances can really damage a child's trust in you. After all, do you really want your children to know that you value them so little?
In essence, do your utmost to ensure that your children always feel loved, wanted, protected, and respected by BOTH parents. At a time when they may feel their whole world is crashing down on them, this is crucial.
In Summary
Whatever you do, keep in mind that you are the same two people who once loved each other enough to share every aspect of your lives together. Most especially, if you have children, never forget that your spouse will always be a major part of your children's lives. If you can put aside your differences long enough to remember this, then I predict that you'll make it through with both friendship and dignity intact.
HOW TO REDUCE YOUR ATTORNEY'S BILL
An attorney's fees are determined in one of three ways:
- On a per-hour basis, with each piece of work, each phone call, each letter, each hour of court time being billed separately.
- On a fixed-fee basis, with the entire case being handled for one set fee.
- On a contingency basis, with the attorney taking his or her fees out of any award won by the client.
In a contingency case, of course, the fees take care of themselves. In a fixed-fee situation, you will pay the same no matter what. However, there are ways in which you can greatly reduce the amount of your final bill when you are being charged on a per-hour basis.
- Be prepared. When you first meet with your attorney, bring with you everything you feel you might need to get the case started. Most importantly, try to determine ahead of time exactly what it is you hope to get out of your case. If you provide your lawyer with a complete package, he will spend far less billable time trying to determine exactly what it is that you want and what information he requires from you to achieve that goal.
- Be concise. When meeting with your attorney, or talking with him on the phone, try to stick to the point. When the conversation moves into irrelevant areas, you must remember that you are still paying for that time.
- Consolidate. Don't call your attorney every time you have a question or a concern, unless it is of overwhelming importance. Wait until you have several questions or comments and present them to him at the same time.
- Put it in writing. It is easier to stay on track and present your ideas effectively in a letter than it is over the phone. Plus you have the added advantage of having a permanent record of your concerns with less likelihood of a misunderstanding occurring.
- Be patient. In any legal case, there are long periods of waiting time, such as when you are awaiting a hearing date or a signed divorce decree from the judge. Ask your attorney up-front how long certain things should take. Once you have that information, be patient. Constant calls to your attorney to check on the status of that item will only increase your bill. You may be certain that the moment your attorney receives the information, the signed decree, or whatever else you are awaiting, you will be immediately notified. Of course, if the waiting period seems to be unusually long, it is certainly reasonable to make a quick call to see what's happening.
- Consider your options carefully. Many clients feel that an attorney is not doing his job unless a veritable blizzard of motions and petitions and notices are being filed. Before asking your attorney to prepare any pleading, consider whether it is really necessary - ask yourself what you are likely to gain from that action. And always keep in mind that you are being billed for that action - so think carefully.
- Take on some of the work yourself. Each thing that you do on your own behalf is one less thing that your attorney will have to do - and bill for. For example, when you bring in a pile of documents, it makes good sense to have them well-organized, perhaps even providing an index. That way your attorney will not have to spend valuable time trying to organize them himself. When your attorney requests certain information from you, try to provide it as soon as possible --that way, there will be fewer follow-up calls and reminder letters. If you communicate in writing to your attorney, type the document rather than handwriting it - trying to decipher a handwritten document can really increase the amount of time your lawyer must spend on it. If documents or evidence must be picked up from a distant location, offer to pick the items up yourself if possible. For an attorney, travel time is also billable time.
- Be realistic. Some items are simply not worth fighting over, especially when it's "a matter of principle". You may find winning a point comes at a very high price.
- Be reasonable. Never let the emotion of the moment blind you to the essential fairness of your actions. While you should always make sure that the other party is not taking unfair advantage, keep in mind that the more honest you are in dealing with the situation the more likely it is that the other party will be the same. Trying to "take them to the cleaners" will almost always result in a whopper of a legal bill.
- Avoid trial whenever possible. Taking a case to trial always involves great expense, both financially and emotionally. Always try to work things out without taking that final step. Remember, one way or another, an agreement WILL be reached in your case - if you don't come to a decision by yourselves, I guarantee the judge will do it for you.
In short, the best way to ensure that your legal bills remain within reason is to keep your two feet planted firmly on the ground and to keep your mind firmly fixed on the goal of obtaining a fair and expedient resolution to your case. Confusion, disorganization, bitterness, and anger on your part will only benefit one person - your attorney, in the form of the higher fees he will be able to charge.
FAMILY LAW MYTHS IN ALABAMA
Many myths emerge from conversations concerning Family Law. Recently, at the annual meeting of the Alabama Bar Association, I was talking with a group of fellow lawyers concerning some of the problems we have been seeing among our clients. One major problem we found is that our clients are receiving second-hand information from their barbers, bartenders, and other well-meaning friends. These individuals, although intending to be helpful, are often quite off-base with facts concerning the law, and therefore misguide our clients.
One of the most common myths is that a child always gets to choose which parent that child wishes to live with, especially when the child reaches a certain age. In truth, many factors must be considered by the Judge in making custody determinations, including: 1) the sex and age of the child; 2) characteristics and needs of the child; 3) respective home environments offered by each parent; 4) the parental characteristics of each parent; 5) the capacity and interest of each parent in providing for the emotional, social, material, and educational needs of the child; 6) the interpersonal relationship between the child and the parent; 7) the effect on the child of interrupting or disrupting a continuing custodial status; 8) the report and recommendation of any expert witnesses; and 9) the available alternatives and any other relevant matter which may be present.
Another myth which needs to be addressed is that if one party contracts a sexually-transmitted disease from a spouse and then goes through a divorce, there is no remedy available for reimbursement of that party's medical bills incurred as a result of the infection. However, in Alabama, there is an affirmative duty on the part of a person infected with a sexually-transmitted disease to inform a potential sexual partner of such prior to sexual contact - failure to do so is a Class "C" Misdemeanor. For a spouse to transmit a sexually-transmitted disease to their partner gives an additional action in the divorce case for what is known as an Interspousal Tort. Thus, upon proof of the spouse's wrongful conduct, the other spouse may be entitled to damages.
I have heard this statement many times: "My spouse and I have come to an agreement for a divorce and want to use the same lawyer as advertised in a local publication for $200.00." The Alabama Rules of Professional Conduct strictly prohibits one attorney from representing both parties. One attorney may draw up all of the papers for both parties only if they are in agreement with all the provisions. However, that lawyer only represents one of the parties - the other must sign a statement to the effect that they understand that the attorney does not represent them and that they have been advised to retain counsel of their own and have refused. With regard to the $200.00 divorces advertised in local publications, potential clients must always be aware that the advertised amount does not include expenses (such as the court filing fee of approximately $150.00). And, although I am sure that there have been some happy couples who have obtained a $200.00 divorce, the area is replete with many horror stories concerning these. A colleague of mine relayed one instance in which a cut-price lawyer obtained a divorce for a couple. Unbeknownst to the attorney, the mother was pregnant at the time of the divorce. Later, she petitioned the Court for child support. Since all issues regarding child support, pregnancy, and the like were left unaddressed in the divorce decree, the mother is now without any type of support or remedy.
Many people also believe that it is only the father who will be ordered to pay child support - however, gender is not a consideration in requiring the non-custodial parent to pay support. Although it is true that more men than women are paying child support to an ex-spouse, increasingly the father is becoming a custodial parent and more women are now paying child support to their ex-husbands.
Some people also feel that since their spouse has not paid child support for two months that they can withhold two months visitation. These two provisions of the divorce decree operate independently. If the custodial parent withholds visitation, he/she could be put in jail for contempt of court. Likewise, if the non-custodial parent does not pay support, he/she could also be jailed. A better approach would be to file a petition to hold the other spouse in contempt for violation of the court decree - don't take the law into your own hands.
I have often wondered why people seek out specialists for their medical problems but depend on the advice of their friends in solving Family Law problems. Speak with an attorney who is knowledgeable concerning Family Law in Alabama for the best answers to your questions. Otherwise, you may find yourself "jumping out of the frying pan into the fire".
DETERMINATION OF CHILD SUPPORT
In August of 1989, the Alabama Supreme Court adopted what is known as Rule 32, Alabama Rules of Judicial Administration, otherwise known as the Child Support Guidelines. Child support is based upon the gross incomes of each parent, with the party paying for the child's medical insurance premium and day care costs receiving a credit for such payments. If one party pays child support or alimony from a previous marriage, this would also be taken into account. The amount of child support is therefore determined according to a fixed formula, and Judges in Alabama are extremely reluctant to deviate from that standard, even in cases where the custodial parent agrees to voluntarily accept a lower amount. It should always be understood that child support is not paid for the benefit of the custodial parent, but rather for the benefit of the child - therefore, the custodial parent may not arbitrarily agree to a lower amount as the court would usually not consider that to be in the best interest of the child. One exception which is usually considered by the Court is in cases where the non-custodial parent must travel long distances to exercise visitation, thereby incurring substantial travel expense. In such cases, the court will usually consider a request for reduced child support.
Child support is paid to the custodial parent in one of several ways:
- Direct payment from one parent to the other, either by check or in cash. Whenever the custodial parent accepts a cash payment for child support, it is ESSENTIAL that a written receipt be given acknowledging the payment - otherwise no proof will exist that the payment was ever made.
- Payment made by the non-custodial parent to the court clerk's office, which will then be sent to the custodial parent.
- Payment made to the custodial parent's attorney, which will be forwarded to the custodial parent.
- Through an Income Withholding Order served on the non-custodial parent's employer, whereby the employer withholds the amount of child support from the parent's paycheck and sends it to the court clerk's office, who then forwards the amount to the custodial parent.
It should always be kept in mind that payment of child support, in full and on time, is an obligation, not a choice. A non-custodial parent may not arbitrarily reduce court-ordered payments for any reason. If the non-custodial parent believes that the child support amount is unjust, a petition to modify the court order should be filed with the court, and a hearing will be set to determine whether or not the support amount should be modified. In the end, it is always best to consult your attorney before taking any action to ensure that you are always in compliance with the law.